Which RP is Better? Martell's or Fappy's?

Just conducting a survey to get opinions, also fill free to make suggestions that will make both rps better.

C. None of the above

D. Modern World RP
of course!
omg omg omg

Well this is a poll to determine which one of the two is better in peoples opinions, Im not adding all rps as options, and also for option C, you can just not post or vote that's entirely up to you.

...this is a joke, right?

"Better" is entirely subjective. Neither RP is universally "better," and will never be until and unless the original poster provides a clearer metric of "better."

I agree with International... what do you mean by better? More capable of units spamming? More ridiculously op units? More cities? I do not find any of them good enough to determine which might be better in my opinion but at least you should be a bit more precise with the meaning of better. For me the one that has the less income and unbalanced units would be the "best".

I think he just means which RP do you like better.

This..... i enjoyed rp,tempted rp i mean, i was ok with the spam and shitty borders,but then it was replaced by martell's, the thing makes tempted rp looks balanced,
EDIT: i vote c, tempted rp

Skrivet av Mr_Own_U, 30.03.2015 at 22:07

C. None of the above

RP in Your Mother's bed, she's the world trade center and I am the plane

Well, by better I would say balanced incomes, redefined units and realism in some way according to modern day world, even tho Roleplay has a bad rep for the faggy incomes are overpowered units, it can be still be a good map to play, if played accordingly and good, I respect people that dont like RP that much, but in my point of view, I tbh only play RP for the concept of it, which is in theory good-ish, but hey, communism was good too and look at it now lol

I will says none but i voted for fappy, because martell rp is getting old

Honestly, I think they're both pretty decent. @Everyone who is saying 'neither is better, it's subjective!!' and everything like that, she's asking for personal opinions, not some magically standard of judging. Both have things that could be improved, as does everything in the world.

Anyways, I voted for Martells, if only to try to balance out votes. Also because Bouvet Island <3

If u played mine u would realise I have Added bouvet Island and several other islands like the Spraty and Palau x)

Skrivet av Al Fappino, 31.03.2015 at 20:41

If u played mine u would realise I have Added bouvet Island and several other islands like the Spraty and Palau x)

Last time I played your map, you got me kicked because of my clan. x)

Skrivet av Al Fappino, 31.03.2015 at 20:41

If u played mine u would realise I have Added bouvet Island and several other islands like the Spraty and Palau x)

I'm not sure when having a good map was based on how many Pacific and Arctic Islands you have.

Skrivet av ManlyMan, 31.03.2015 at 11:03

I think he just means which RP do you like better.

In that case, I choose to abstain.

There are many good things in RP, but the quality of its maps is not one of them.

Skrivet av ManlyMan, 31.03.2015 at 23:28

Skrivet av Al Fappino, 31.03.2015 at 20:41

If u played mine u would realise I have Added bouvet Island and several other islands like the Spraty and Palau x)

I'm not sure when having a good map was based on how many Pacific and Arctic Islands you have.

I didnt say that either...

Skrivet av Talvari, 31.03.2015 at 23:24

Skrivet av Al Fappino, 31.03.2015 at 20:41

If u played mine u would realise I have Added bouvet Island and several other islands like the Spraty and Palau x)

Last time I played your map, you got me kicked because of my clan. x)

Well i dont remember that, probably did x) anyway be free to play my map, Jarl Magnus

Skrivet av Al Fappino, 01.04.2015 at 05:57

Skrivet av ManlyMan, 31.03.2015 at 23:28

Skrivet av Al Fappino, 31.03.2015 at 20:41

If u played mine u would realise I have Added bouvet Island and several other islands like the Spraty and Palau x)

I'm not sure when having a good map was based on how many Pacific and Arctic Islands you have.

I didnt say that either...

Excuse me for that, apparently when I didn't see Sweyn's message before that about Bouvet, and I thought you were implying the map was better because it had islands.

Skrivet av Al Fappino, 31.03.2015 at 19:57

Hm... I've only tried adog's and tempted's RP maps. Adog's RP was the best one by far in my opinion. Why? Not so much unit spamming possibilities. Incomes were reasonable and kinda balanced. No faggy units with overpowered attack/defense values which made the game completely retarded, just a few special units for some countries to give some excitement. Also, these units weren't that OP compared to the basic units, which helps making a map more balanced. Another thing I loved is the possibility of picking different strategies! In Tempted's RP, blitz is too OP and is barely the only viable strat. I don't completely hate the RP concept eventhough sometimes... it becomes too faggy. People take advantage over those rules just to gangbang a single player or whatever. Also, temped's RP is merely a place to spam units, which is kinda sad and boring.

Idk about both these RPs that are being voted as if the winner would get a prize but which ever has the lowest spamming rate, the lowest income and balanced units and reinforcements should be the best.

Skrivet av Al Fappino, 01.04.2015 at 05:58

I took a quick glance at your map, specially at Spain. I find it a mix of Adog's RP and Tempted's RP. Also, just by looking at Spain, I already didn't like it, not realistic. What did you base your reinforcements number on? I happen to find too many "elite" units, which is taken from Tempted's RP, which are heavily buffed compared to standard units. I didn't even try to find out but I'm also guessing you buffed pretty much all income, and not just a bit. So... nah, I don't like your RP.

Skrivet av RaulPB, 01.04.2015 at 07:06

Skrivet av Al Fappino, 31.03.2015 at 19:57

Hm... I've only tried adog's and tempted's RP maps. Adog's RP was the best one by far in my opinion. Why? Not so much unit spamming possibilities. Incomes were reasonable and kinda balanced. No faggy units with overpowered attack/defense values which made the game completely retarded, just a few special units for some countries to give some excitement. Also, these units weren't that OP compared to the basic units, which helps making a map more balanced. Another thing I loved is the possibility of picking different strategies! In Tempted's RP, blitz is too OP and is barely the only viable strat. I don't completely hate the RP concept eventhough sometimes... it becomes too faggy. People take advantage over those rules just to gangbang a single player or whatever. Also, temped's RP is merely a place to spam units, which is kinda sad and boring.

Idk about both these RPs that are being voted as if the winner would get a prize but which ever has the lowest spamming rate, the lowest income and balanced units and reinforcements should be the best.

No prize or anything this is just an opinion I want to hear from everyone. Just trying to collect information because perhaps I might get back into map making and actually release a new map. Who knows, just curious to see what the community thinks of these two RPs now as they are the most played currently.

If u would know from Tempted RP, u would realise Spain was very underpowered in relation with the remaining of Europe, so I made it competitive enough with other european nations, yes I admit it might be a bit too much overpowered, but I'll give it a look when I got the time. If you dont like my RP good, but if u never you cant have a strong opinion about it.
Regarding to the elite units, whar do you mean? And like Pepsigal said, this is a survey, not a discussion.

Skrivet av Al Fappino, 02.04.2015 at 11:14

If u would know from Tempted RP, u would realise Spain was very underpowered in relation with the remaining of Europe, so I made it competitive enough with other european nations, yes I admit it might be a bit too much overpowered, but I'll give it a look when I got the time. If you dont like my RP good, but if u never you cant have a strong opinion about it.
Regarding to the elite units, whar do you mean? And like Pepsigal said, this is a survey, not a discussion.

Yeah, I see. Well, my opinion might not matter much to you since I'm more of a competitive player and I value much more other aspects that the RP do not value much.
As a spanish guy I must say Spain is really really overpowered, cities that are insignificant have too many reinforcements and even more than other cities that are far stronger. I'm not sure in what you base your map, either reality or imagination, but it's just too much of a spamming unit map. I don't know where RP'ers get this idea that the more you can spam, the funnier a map is.

PS: I actually think that Tempted's Spain was better/more realistic maybe than yours. I also think it was a bit more balanced compared to some other Eu countries. Your Spain seems even stronger than UK? All I need to know is in what are you basing your map...

Skrivet av Al Fappino, 02.04.2015 at 11:14

If u would know from Tempted RP, u would realise Spain was very underpowered in relation with the remaining of Europe, so I made it competitive enough with other european nations, yes I admit it might be a bit too much overpowered, but I'll give it a look when I got the time. If you dont like my RP good, but if u never you cant have a strong opinion about it.
Regarding to the elite units, whar do you mean? And like Pepsigal said, this is a survey, not a discussion.

I'm not sure when I'm not allowed to have a strong opinion if I've never done it. I can look at a map and tell whether or not I like it.

Citera:

Skrivet av Ghost-IV, 02.04.2015 at 10:39

which ever has the lowest spamming rate, the lowest income and balanced units and reinforcements should be the best.

No prize or anything this is just an opinion I want to hear from everyone. Just trying to collect information because perhaps I might get back into map making and actually release a new map. Who knows, just curious to see what the community thinks of these two RPs now as they are the most played currently.

I stated my opinion as you can see... but I'm afraid this is not the kind of opinion you're expecting to read. As the forum is full of 3 vs 3 or competitive players... I don't think you can find the answers you seek in this forum... in my opinion, you should ask this question to the players you know who play RP, they will give you the kind of answer your expecting to hear.

I respect all opinions, and I've asked many people what RP they think its best and some say they are tied and others say mine and others say its Martell's, so there isnt really a defined opinion regarding to the RP's, yet


Barron, by looking at it u can wether like it or not, and I respect that.

Skrivet av Al Fappino, 02.04.2015 at 11:36

Still, you haven't answered my only question... I would really appreciate to know in what did you base your map, cities, income, reinf, etc? Realistic, imaginary, balance, epic?

By map, Fappy's, considering it has everything Martell has, except the aland islands and a lot of weird country splits. by gameplay,they feel the same,so.... both. Then again i have only played like five fappy rp games, so i really can't have a opinion.